Tag Archives: Clean Rooms

New Products


January 1, 2007

Refrigeration cells

Click here to enlarge image

Viessmann Kältetechnik AG combines refrigeration and cleanroom technology for the protection of sensitive production and research processes with its new Cleanroom Refrigeration Cells. Suitable for the storage of natural sample and pharmaceutical raw materials, these refrigeration cells deliver the highest standard of cleanliness to the demanding life science sector. Featuring modular construction, the refrigeration cells are built to impede the penetration of moisture and contamination. In addition, an optional antimicrobial surface coating provides active and enduring protection against microorganisms. Other features include: flat fitting of the flooring element with radius strips; a cold-room door with a slope for access control and security; and an interior built-in lighting unit with low-temperature lighting. All air conducting elements are integrated in the cell in compliance with GMP, and filter modules recessed in the ceiling or side walls feature easily dismantled and cleanable return-air shafts with optional prefilter cartridges.

Viessmann Kältetechnik
Hof, Germany
www.vkag.de

Sterilizable RFID tag

Click here to enlarge image

The GammaTag™ is the first and only read/write radio frequency identification (RFID) tag that’s safely sterilizable by gamma radiation. It provides reliable electronic identification and data storage of single-use/disposable components used in critical process industries, such as pharmaceutical, bioprocess/biomedical, food and beverage, and medical device. GammaTag easily attaches to components such as sample and production bags, tanks, filters, manifolds, tubing and hose, storage vessels, and to complete single-use systems. Several attachment methods (e.g., silicone tape, watchband style holders, pouches, and lamination) are available. The tag withstands gamma radiation up to 45 kGy (kilograys) and temperatures from -20°C to +85°C (-4°F to +185°F). The read/write ability makes the tag unique because data can be written directly on the tag, unlike read-only bar code labels or tags. In conjunction with a handheld tag reader and software (known as Process Equipment Tracking [PET]), GammaTag allows access to the current status of process components.

AdvantaPure, a division of NewAge Industries, Inc.
Southampton, PA
www.advantapure.com

Aseptic filling system

Click here to enlarge image

The FMB210 filler from Flexicon America offers an aseptic filling process that combines the security of sterile containment and gentle peristaltic dispensing action to safely and accurately fill injectable products into vials. Flexicon filling technology features a sterile fill channel that assures repeatable accuracy in fill volumes. The modular design of the FMB210 monobloc system is well suited for contract outsource manufacturers who require flexible, Just-in-Time solutions for filling and capping of lyophilized injectables. Since product comes in contact only with the medical-grade silicone tubing and the filling needle, there is no risk of product cross-contamination between batches or between product changeover. With only a simple change of the tubing and fill needle, and a format change to accommodate size variations in vials and caps, the FMB210 is ready to accommodate a new product in less than 10 minutes. Optimum design of laminar airflow guards provides maximum protection to open vials. The FMB210 monobloc can be adapted for full-system integration into isolators.

Flexicon America, Inc.
Burlington, VT
www.flexiconamerica.com

Wafer shipping box

Click here to enlarge image

The new Ultrapak® Edge Guard 200 mm wafer shipping box from Entegris, Inc. provides reduced edge contamination in a secure shipping environment. According to the company, users can expect to see a reduction of 50 percent or greater in particle contamination due to edge contact. In addition, horizontal and vertical robotic pick-up flanges on the cassette allow for convenient handling, while center-notch track alignment and “H” bar features ensure accurate equipment interoperability.

Entegris, Inc.
Chaska, MN
www.entegris.com

Low-level moisture measurement

Click here to enlarge image

HygroTrace™ from GE Sensing uses a newly patented technique to provide accurate and reliable measurement for 0 to 100 parts-per-billion (ppb) moisture levels critical to a variety of semiconductor, LCD, and other manufacturing processes. Typical semiconductor applications include measurement of moisture in UHP gas delivery and distribution systems and point-of-use moisture measurement protection. The HygroTrace uses aluminum oxide technology with a new technique that improves sensor speed of response to provide ppb moisture measurement in minutes. In addition, the meter has the form factor of a transmitter package with the only wetted parts being essentially a flow-through 1⁄4-inch VCR tee fitting. The HygroTrace package is 80 to 90 percent smaller than competitive analyzers and costs 50 to 70 percent less. The instrument features a large, integrated backlit display, which users can easily read from several feet away. A six-button keypad allows users to program the unit for output range and to check on performance. The unit is loop-powered using a 20-28 VDC source and provides a 4-20 mA output proportional to a user-programmed range.

GE Sensing
Billerica, MA
www.gesensing.com

Vented spikes

Click here to enlarge image

Qosina now offers vented spikes with bacteria-proof ventilation, hydrophobic filters and female luer locks. The latex-free, PVC-free spikes are engineered for ergonomic fluid transfer with a low piercing force and priming volume. The 2.5-inch-long spikes have MABS housing, PTFE membranes and polypropylene caps, and they are available with color-coded green, blue or red protective safety snap caps that open and close with one hand. The blue- and red-capped spikes have an additional 5-micron particle filter. The blue and green versions have an opaque white body, while the red spike has a clear body.

Qosina
Edgewood, NY
www.qosina.com

Disposable filter assembly

Click here to enlarge image

Meissner introduces the UltraCap® H.D. (Heavy Duty) high-capacity disposable filter assembly for liquid, gas, and vent applications. It is a completely disposable, high-flow, high-throughput filter system designed to process medium to large liquid batches. The UltraCap H.D. is optimized for continuous and batch processing in biomanufacturing operations and for final and prefiltration in pharmaceutical applications. It is offered with T-style sanitary flange inlet and outlet connections with filter media removal ratings from 0.04 μm to 100 μm. It is available with a variety of membranes and depth media. The assembly resists damage from rough handling conditions and demanding environments. Several length options (10, 20, 30 and 40 inches) allow fast, easy scale-up. UltraCap H.D. is available gamma-irradiated for aseptic applications.

Meissner Filtration Products, Inc.
Camarillo, CA
www.meissner.com

Antimicrobial floor resurfacer

Click here to enlarge image

Valspar Flooring, a division of Valspar, Inc., has announced a major upgrade to its Flowfresh® SR chemical-resistant cementitious urethane floor resurfacer with built-in antimicrobial. Utilizing a proprietary new aggregate, this next generation of Flowfresh SR offers improved thermal shock resistance, withstanding temperatures to 210°F. SR also provides superior protection against impact and abrasions that would scratch, stain or otherwise damage a lesser quality flooring system. Simplified installation, particularly in slope-to-drain areas, ensures quick turnaround. Flowfresh is ideal for resurfacing concrete floors in wet processing areas, and is especially effective in USDA-inspected food, beverage or pharmaceutical plants. A high-performance, natural antimicrobial is integrated into all Flowfresh flooring products to inhibit the growth of bacterial odors, guard against degradation from microorganisms, and prevent the growth of a wide range of harmful microbes. Flowfresh is slip resistant, helping to eliminate or reduce injury risk in wet locations, and the system can be finished with a decorative quartz broadcast to ensure further slip resistance.

Valspar Flooring
Wheeling, IL
www.valsparflooring.com

Indoor air quality monitor

Click here to enlarge image

The new Multinorm from Carltex, Inc. is an all-in-one instrument for monitoring indoor environmental and air quality parameters. Available measurements include air temperature, air velocity, relative humidity, dew point, illuminance, luminance, CO, CO2 and sound (Class 1 and 2) analyses. Additional features of the Multinorm include luminance measurement, contrast, globe temperature, thermocouple (contact temperature), predictive mean vote (PMV), predictive percentage of dissatisfied (PPD), and wet bulb globe temperature (WBGT). Multinorm can operate in two modes: In the online mode it displays current measurements, while in the logger mode, it automatically stores all measurement values per logging interval. Software is included for data analysis, charting and reporting. Firmware is upgradeable for future new probe additions.

Carltex, Inc.
Centerport, NY
www.carltex.com

Fatigue and endurance testing system

Click here to enlarge image

Shimadzu Scientific Instruments’ (SSI) ADT-A Series Air Servo meets the needs of high-precision fatigue and endurance testing while addressing the challenges of the cleanroom environment. It features pneumatic operation, reducing impact on the environment. The instruments require no hydraulic fluid, eliminating the need for fluid maintenance, replenishment and disposal along with the possibility of environmental contamination.

Shimadzu Scientific Instruments, Inc.
Columbia, MD
www.ssi.shimadzu.com

Miniature micropump

Click here to enlarge image

A new 4μL micropump available from Bio-Chem Valve and Omnifit accurately and efficiently dispenses low-pressure microflows of high-purity or aggressive liquids. The miniature, faster-cycling, microdispensing Model 030 pump achieves greater output by cycling at up to 4 Hz. Designed for speed in cycling, the miniature, lightweight pump utilizes a fast-response solenoid that is capable of quickly dispensing microvolumes. The pump offers up to 20 million dispense cycles and features low power consumption, minimal heat generation, low internal volume and a positive shut-off. The diaphragm is made of PTFE; the pump body is formed of P.P.S. as a standard; and the check valve is DuPont Viton® or FKM. The Model 030 is designed for flexibility to meet a wide range of footprints and profiles for use in medical and laboratory instrumentation and manufacturing applications. The simple addition of a screw nut offers a quick-change manifold mount connection.

Bio-Chem Valve Inc. and Omnifit, Ltd.
Boonton, NJ
www.bio-chemvalve.com

Gas purification system

Click here to enlarge image

Entegris, Inc. has introduced its Extreme Clean Dry Air (XCDA®) gas purification system for use as a safer and more cost-effective alternative to conventional nitrogen gas purging in reticle pods and stockers. XCDA purified, clean, dry air is as chemically clean as, and about 40 percent less expensive than, house nitrogen and has none of the asphyxiation risks associated with continuous nitrogen purge. The dual-bed, self-regenerating design purifiers contain clean, dry air to maintain a continuous flow of ultrapure gas.

Entegris, Inc.
Chaska, MN
www.entegris.com

Compact, radial fans

Click here to enlarge image

Rosenberg’s new family of compact radial fans with free-running impellers and variable speeds combine electronically commutated external rotor motors with newly developed integrated power electronics. The new fans’ (models GKHR and GKHM) long-life, low-temperature, brushless DC motors are controlled by maintenance-free electronic circuitry. GKHR fans are motorized impellers, mounted and balanced, that may be provided with or without an inlet cone. GKHM fans are complete fan modules. The external rotor design and high power density make the fans ideal for use in ventilation and air conditioning applications. With reduced mechanical content, the fan motors run cooler and quieter, require little or no maintenance and can be speed-controlled using an external potentiometer or 0-10V PWM signal. The new EC motors deliver highly efficient, low-noise performance without using collectors and carbon brushes, which can wear out and shorten motor life. The new models also feature power supply and control leads that connect directly at the motor, simplifying installation. In pressure control applications, the EC motors can be direct-connected to a pressure sensor. In master-slave designs, the pressure-controlled output of the master fan controls slave-unit speeds. Networking is accomplished by linking fan motor electronics to a computer using an RS485 interface.

Rosenberg USA
Indian Trail, NC
www.rosenbergusa.com

Stainless-steel garment racks

Click here to enlarge image

Clean Air Products introduces the Series 38ST garment rack, a rugged stainless-steel wire hanger rack available in 3-, 4-, 5-, 6- and 8-foot lengths. Racks can have single or double rows for access from both sides. A variety of hanger styles and options are available to suit specific application needs, including removable open-loop, non-removable closed-loop, or “no take” removable hangers with labels and hanger spacers.

Clean Air Products
Minneapolis, MN
www.cleanairproducts.com

Air, gas flow sensors

Click here to enlarge image

SCHMIDT has introduced a new generation of its SS 20.60 family of air and gas flow sensors. The sensors feature: a measuring range of 200 m/s; turn-down ratio 1 to 1000; calibration accuracy 1 percent of measuring value; sensor tip with high media resistance; availability of analog interface or Profibus-DP or Device-Net interface. The small size of the sensor makes it one of the most compact flow sensors on the market.

SCHMIDT Technology
St. Georgen, Germany
www.schmidttechnology.de

Portable indoor-air purification system

Click here to enlarge image

Zentox now offers the Photox 100W, a portable, advanced, indoor-air purification system that can be wall-mounted or placed on a table. Based on photocatalytic oxidation technology (PCO), the system is designed to destroy noxious odors and toxic vapors, and to inactivate infectious microorganisms in the indoor environment. It does not emit any harmful by-products or ozone, and the destruction of contaminants occurs inside the unit. The system effectively removes a variety of airborne contaminants including bacteria, virus, mold, ammonia, cleaning solvent vapors, paint odor, ozone, hydrogen sulfide, urine/fecal odors, cooking odors, carbon monoxide and formaldehyde. It is ideally suited for use in problem areas in hospitals, medical offices, laboratories, and more. It will effectively purify the air in rooms up to 800 square feet in size. The system is easy to operate and maintain, requiring only the annual replacement of the germicidal UV lamp and the photocatalytic cartridge. The unit weighs only eight pounds, and measures 17” (H) x 14.5” (W) x 8” (D). Photox 100W units have been certified by ETL to meet UL safety standards.

Zentox
Newport News, VA
www.PhotoxPureAir.com

Sanitary barbed connector

Click here to enlarge image

A new style of barbed connector is now available from AdvantaPure. Precision molded with an improved design, these fittings are ideal for the laboratory, food and beverage, pharmaceutical and biopharmaceutical, bioprocess, chemical, purified water, and medical component industries, as well as other applications that call for a lightweight, inert fitting. The new Thermobarb® FDA PP offers several benefits over look-alike connectors, including: elimination of mold parting lines and flashing (waste particles that can dislodge during use and cause contamination); a longer, more tapered lead barb for easier installation, a tighter fit and reduced leakage; smooth surfaces throughout for unrestricted, uniform flow; sterilization by gamma radiation or autoclave; absence of animal-derived ingredients; a temperature range of 10°F to 220°F (-12°C to +104°C). Thermobarb FDA PP fittings conform to USP Class VI standards and are compliant with FDA 21 CFR 177.1520 for food-contact surfaces and RoHS (Restriction of Hazardous Substances). They’re manufactured in the U.S. at an ISO 9002:2000 certified facility. The fittings work well with soft, flexible tubing such as silicone or thermoplastic rubber (TPR) and are ideal connectors for single-use/disposable tubing assemblies in, for example, sampling and fill applications. The connectors are currently available in Y-style in three sizes (1/4”, 3/8”, and 1/2”), but other styles are in development.

AdvantaPure, a division of NewAge Industries, Inc.
Southampton, PA
www.advantapure.com

Single-use filter assembly

Click here to enlarge image

Meissner’s DPS™ (Disposable Processing System) is a pre-assembled, pharmaceutical-grade, single-use filter, tubing and flexible biocontainer system that provides a cost-effective, convenient solution for today’s bioprocessing manufacturing needs. DPS assemblies incorporate the end user’s choice of Meissner’s sterilizing-grade EverLUX™ PES, STyLUX® PES or SteriLUX® PVDF membrane filters. Filter configurations include capsules, UltraCap® high-capacity capsules or UltraCap® H.D. (heavy duty) high-capacity capsules. The assemblies are configured using prevalidated building blocks from Meissner’s component library, and can also be customized to the end user’s requirements for processing 5 L to 2,000 L of biopharmaceutical process liquids and products. The assemblies can be used for sterile filling, dispensing, sampling, transporting, and mixing through temporary hold and long-term storage for many biopharmaceutical process fluids, bulk and purified products. Each assembly is gamma-irradiated and ready for immediate use. DPS is ideal for rapid scale-up or scale-down manufacturing runs.

Meissner Filtration Products, Inc.
Camarillo, CA
www.meissner.com

Low-volume dispensing micropump

Click here to enlarge image

A new generation of the high-accuracy, low-volume dispensing 130 SP micropump from Bio-Chem Valve and Omnifit offers sturdier components within a new body design. The Model 130 SP pump features an all-Teflon fluid path that is sandwiched within a sturdy DELRIN base for a firmer, more stable connection to fittings and/or to a manifold base. The self-priming micropump is constructed with perfluorelastomer check valves and a diaphragm to safely contain and control acidic media, abrasive chemical solutions and cleaning agents within the inert flow channel. Discrete factory-set outputs on the normally closed diaphragm pumps range from 10 μL to 50 μL and can be cycled at up to 2.0 Hz. Flow rates reach up to 6.0 mL/minute. The pump offers up to 20 million dispense cycles and is well suited for rugged laboratory operations in which a wide range of aggressive fluids are used. A cleaning solution can be pumped directly through the fittings and water flushed during process or chemical changeover. Loosening the fittings or removing the manifold screws to install or replace the pump enables fast, easy installation and/or replacement by a laboratory technician or operator.

Bio-Chem Valve, Inc. and Omnifit, Ltd.
Boonton, NJ
www.bio-chemvalve.com

Freestanding air handler

Click here to enlarge image

General Air Corporation’s new environmental air handler model AH-500-TH is designed to provide clean-air, temperature and humidity control for tools requiring precise temperature and humidity control in the semiconductor industry. The air handler is a freestanding enclosure designed to be placed inside a building or cleanroom where some initial form of environmental control already exists. The unit air intake is from the immediate surroundings; the air is then conditioned and filtered in a single pass via a duct directly to the appropriate tool. The unit is suitable for Class 100 (ISO 5) environments.

General Air Corporation
Chatsworth, CA
www.generalair.net

Anti-fatigue mat with static control

Click here to enlarge image

3M’s new Static Control Anti-Fatigue Mat 9900 Series enables workers to stand comfortably for long periods while minimizing the fatigue associated with standing work. In addition, the mats bleed off static electricity as part of a total static control system. The durable rubber mats, which measure 0.60 inches (1.52 cm) thick and have a beveled edge made of solid molded rubber, consist of a matrix of hollow cylinders that function like springs when compressed, providing a durable cushion that offers secure, stable footing and responsiveness. The black mats weigh two pounds per square foot and come in three sizes: standard (3 ft. x 5 ft. [0.9 m x 1.5 m]); octagonal (22-inch diameter [55.9 cm]), and three-foot-wide runners that can be cut to a custom length. Made of SBR rubber polymers, the anti-fatigue mats can be cleaned by sweeping, vacuuming or with a damp mop. They can be used at assembly and manufacturing workstations, warehouse and shipping areas, medical labs, and in field-service applications. They have a resistance in surface-to-ground snap of <1 x 106 ohms and surface-to-ground resistance of <2 x 106 ohms when connected through a 3M brand ground cord 3040. The mats also feature a three-year warranty.

3M
Austin, TX
www.3M.com
Tools for advanced photolithography apps

Tools for advanced photolithography apps

Click here to enlarge image

Entegris, Inc. has introduced several new products for advanced 193 nm (ArF) photolithography applications. These products, which include the Impact® Duo, Impact® Mini, IntelliGen® Mini and Optimizer® ST, provide integrated solutions for the filtration and dispense of photochemicals and other coatings onto the wafer. The Impact Duo filter is designed for advanced photochemical filtration. It combines advanced membrane technologies to provide the highest level of retention. These membrane technologies-sieving and non-sieving-utilize a dual-capture filtration mechanism to ensure that defect-causing impurities are removed from photochemical solutions before reaching the wafer surface. The IntelliGen Mini photochemical dispense system utilizes proprietary two-stage technology and closed-loop pressure control to eliminate particulates and bubbles while providing accurate and repeatable dispense. By detecting variations during photoresist dispense, the IntelliGen Mini dispense system can prevent wafer scrap due to coating problems. The Impact Mini filter is designed to work seamlessly with the IntelliGen Mini dispense system. The filter features an optimized filtration area and hold-up volume intended to minimize chemical waste, shorten filter change-out time and reduce defect levels during semiconductor fabrication. The filter design also utilizes a greater than 60 percent reduction in surface area, thus reducing overall photochemical usage costs. Finally, the Optimizer ST filter provides improved particle retention and cleanliness for point-of-use developer and DI water filtration in ArF processes. The filters are designed to integrate with the company’s Optimizer ST2 manifolds, taking advantage of its patented Connectology® technology for a safe, effective and fast filter change-out.

Entegris, Inc.
Chaska, MN
www.entegris.com

new literature

Optics solutions catalog
Navitar, a global leader of imaging optics technology has released its new 100-page, full-color product catalog. Featuring photos, drawings, and technical specifications, the catalog includes Navitar’s complete product line of optical solutions for machine vision, automation, assembly, imaging, measuring, inspection and biomedical sciences. It contains over 400 products including many new lenses, attachments, adapters, controllers, and illuminators. It features expanded system diagrams, performance specifications, and additional lens accessories for the company’s signature product lines of high and low mag lenses. To request a copy, visit the company’s Web site.

Navitar, Inc.
Rochester, NY
www.machinevision.navitar.com/catalog_request

Cleaning products


December 1, 2006

Cleaning products are a vital part of ensuring that a clean environment is sterile and contaminant-free. But the type of clean space in question and the level of cleanliness that must be maintained will determine which products will accommodate your specific needs. This month’s spotlight offers a selection of solutions, wipes, and more, to keep your critical environment operating at peak cleanliness levels.

Compiled by Angela Godwin

Click here to enlarge image

General-purpose wipers
Nova-Tech 1000 cleanroom wipes from Blue Thunder Technologies are general-purpose, nonwoven wipers that are absorbent, strong, and ideal for general wiping purposes. They are composed of a unique blend of absorbent cellulose and polyester to create low particle emissions levels as well as minimal nonvolatile residue and ions. These wipers are ideal for Class 100 to 10,000 [ISO 5 to 7] cleanrooms and are double-bagged with lot-to-lot traceability.

Blue Thunder Technologies
East Windsor, CT
www.bluethundertechnologies.com

Click here to enlarge image

Cleaning system
Contec’s EasyReach Cleaning System allows users to effectively clean hard-to-reach vertical and horizontal surfaces. It extends reach, to clean over and under heavy equipment, hard surface floors and walls. The cleaning system utilizes a variety of dry and presaturated wipes that attach to a lightweight 4-inch x 10-inch (10.2 cm x 25.4 cm) mop head. It is compatible with many Contec substrates for wet or dry cleaning applications. Anodized aluminum extension handles are available in two lengths, 4 feet (1.25 meters) and 8 feet (2.5 meters).

Contec, Inc.
Spartanburg, SC
www.contecinc.com

Critical surface wipers

Click here to enlarge image

KIMTECH PURE* CL3 Wipers with patent-pending Clean-Dry Technology from Kimberly-Clark Professional can be used for the most critical surface-wiping tasks in ISO Class 3 or higher cleanroom environments. The wipers are 100 percent continuous filament double-knit polyester. They absorb liquids on contact while still delivering the low particle and extractable levels expected from polyester wipers. KIMTECH PURE* CL3 Wipers are solvent- and abrasion-resistant, have four laser-sealed edges to minimize particle generation, are cleanroom laundered in water filtered to 0.2 micron to minimize the potential for ion contamination, and are double-bagged to maintain cleanliness. The wipers are also compliant with AAMI guidelines and gamma irradiated to a 10-6 Sterility Assurance Level (SAL).

Kimberly-Clark Professional
Roswell, GA
www.kcprofessional.com

Click here to enlarge image

Aqueous waterless cleaning
PDQ Precision, Inc. manufactures and distributes the Mini-Max Cleaning and Waste Management Systems, which are particularly useful where pinpoint or precision cleaning is desired. This FDA-registered Class II device for cleaning medical equipment (E197753) has a variable steam vapor output (from 195 psi to 295 psi and from 500°F up to 1300°F) depending on user needs and applications. Laboratory tests have shown that sanitation and sterilization can be achieved with these systems as well (cleaning bacteria and removing spores from surfaces, as shown by NAMSA Labs results 06/04).

PDQ Precision, Inc.
San Diego, CA
www.minimaxcleaner.com

Click here to enlarge image

Gamma irradiated disinfectant
Sporicidin offers its Disinfectant Solution and Gamma Irradiated Disinfectant Solution, both of which are FDA- and EPA-registered to provide 100 percent kill of all pathogenic vegetative organisms. The solutions are tuberculocidal, bactericidal, fungicidal and virucidal (lipophilic and hydrophilic), including oral, ocular and genital herpes and HIV-1 (AIDS virus). They are registered for use on hospital instruments and equipment and comply with the OSHA Bloodborne Pathogens Standard. The Gamma Irradiated Sporicidin gallon is double-bagged and ISO-11137-validated for sterility assurance for use in pharmaceutical cleanrooms and other critical environments. Sporicidin products are alcohol-free and are safe for surfaces, including stainless steel, glass, Formica, paint, chrome, vinyl and wood. No rotation is necessary.

Sporicidin International
Rockville, MD
www.sporicidin.com

New products


December 1, 2006

Compiled by Angela Godwin

Click here to enlarge image

Wire Belt Company of America, a leading developer of advanced conveyor belting solutions, has introduced the new Compact Grid™ Conveyor Belt, designed specifically to handle smaller, more delicate products, while providing a lighter weight, lower mass, and an open-mesh belt design that is ideal for high-speed cooling and drying operations. Engineered with a 70 percent open surface area, the Compact Grid is suitable for processes in which product coating, drainage, and liquid or air circulation are factors. The open stainless-steel design is ideal for cooking operations such as frying and baking, as well as for cooling freshly baked or freshly fried products in high-volume, high-throughput processes. The increased open area makes the Compact Grid easy to clean and maintain. Offering a tight wrap capability, the Compact Grid allows for improved conveyor-to-conveyor transfers, minimizing the chance for product yield loss in high-speed processing operations. Its rugged construction offers maximum strength under significant loads, lessening the time needed to maintain the conveying system and reducing the number of belt replacements over time.

Wire Belt Company of America
Londonderry, NH
www.wirebelt.com

Labeling system

The new Multivac 6000 Cross Web Labeling System features a redesigned dispensing head for optimal sanitation, easier operation with touch-panel display, and increased cycle speeds to accelerate production by as much as 33 percent. Its state-of-the-art design also ensures lower maintenance costs. The system applies a wide range of label sizes and can be used for RFID label placement. Suitable for applications in food, medical and consumer product manufacturing.

Multivac
Kansas City, MO
www.multivac.com

Filters for wafer cleaning apps

Click here to enlarge image

Pall Corporation recently introduced the new Excellar ER filter, a 0.02-micron-rated filter that provides enhanced retention for improved contamination control, especially for critical newly emerging 65 nm and 45 nm device generations. This is the newest addition to the company’s UltiKleen™ Excellar family of PTFE non-dewetting filter membranes, offering chipmakers a suite of PTFE membranes that support filtration needs in critical wafer cleaning applications down to the 20-nanometer size of particle removal. These filters were specifically designed for the aqueous-based, gas-generating chemicals used in wafer cleaning.

Pall Corporation
East Hills, NY
www.pall.com

Ductless fume hoods

Click here to enlarge image

Air Science USA has introduced its EDU Mobile Ductless Fume Hoods, which offer a low cost solution for clean air requirements. Designed to provide operator protection when using hazardous substances, the fume hoods feature: high-quality prefilter and carbon filters with efficiencies superior to 99.6 percent; mobility from laboratory to laboratory; easy installation with no ducting; and alarms that monitor filter, airflow, and filter lifetime.

Air Science USA
Fort Myers, FL
www.air-science.com

Silicone-based packaging material

Click here to enlarge image

NuSil Technology, a manufacturer of silicone-based materials for healthcare, aerospace, electronics and photonics, recently announced the addition of EPM-2411-2, a low outgassing, one-part, silicone glop-top, to its line of electronic packaging materials (EPMs). The material is designed for the encapsulation of chip packages in devices where outgassing-related contamination poses a problem. The product exhibits the low stress and wide operating temperature ranges that are characteristically associated with silicone-based materials. It is stored and shipped frozen in 3 cc and 30 cc syringes, as well as 3- and 6-ounce tubes.

NuSil Technology
Carpinteria, CA
www.nusil.com

Cleanroom tables

Click here to enlarge image

Clean Air Products has introduced Series 64 perforated stainless-steel cleanroom tables. The tables allow uniform airflow through the work surface, and eliminate eddies and stagnant air pockets that can exist on or above the work surface of solid-top tables. They feature a stainless-steel support frame and are ideal for vertical-flow cleanroom applications. Continuous-top and perimeter-frame models are available.

Clean Air Products
Minneapolis, MN
www.cleanairproducts.com

Vibration isolation workstation

Click here to enlarge image

Minus K Technology, Inc., in a joint venture with Kinetic Systems, has released the MK26 Series Vibration Control Workstation™, specifically designed for ultralow natural frequency applications and negative stiffness vibration isolators, to provide a compact, passive vibration isolation workstation with excellent vertical and horizontal isolation efficiencies. The workstation is appropriate for a wide range of instruments, including analytical balances, cell injection, confocal microscopes, patch clamping, optical microscopes, wafer probing, sensor calibration, atomic force microscopes and other sensitive equipment used in semiconductor processing, telecommunications, aerospace engineering, and medical research. It can be configured for a wide variety of applications and customized with a broad range of vibration isolation workstation accessories. Other features include: ultralow natural frequencies; vibradamped frame; customizable accessories; easy to use, with no air supply or electric power needed; choice of tabletops; ergonomic styling; Class 100 [ISO 5] cleanroom compatibility, with Class 10 [ISO 4] available; and no maintenance.

Minus K Technology, Inc.
Inglewood, CA
www.minusk.com

Non-slip floor coating

Click here to enlarge image

Stop-Slip™ HDV from Garon Products is a strong, chemical-resistant coating that offers non-slip traction. The high-performance coating is ideal for chemical, printing, or food processing plants. The aggressive “peak and valley” profile provides superior traction and prevents hydroplaning even when wet. With low odor and virtually no VOCs, it is suitable for indoor applications. The USDA-approved coating applies easily with a trowel or roller, and dries in 24 to 48 hours to a durable, easy-to-clean surface.

Garon Products, Inc.
Wall, NJ
>www.garonproducts.com

Filtration/containment system

Click here to enlarge image

Fette, a leading manufacturer and supplier of tablet presses for both pharmaceutical and industrial applications, now offers Fette ABSOLUT filtration/containment systems for the containment and removal of active-compound and toxic-product dust during industrial and pharmaceutical production. The system filters extremely fine dust particles and aerosols, bringing pharmaceutical processing contamination levels down well below the most stringent occupational exposure limits (OEL). The system provides an extremely low airborne dust level during handling via the use of two HEPA filters that allow cleaned air to be reintroduced back into the production area with no impact on room-to-hallway air balancing. It features the use of submicron particulate filter cassettes in both the active filter and safety filter stages, providing: the ability to accept high levels of contaminants in the inlet air stream; guaranteed 24-hour system operation; the ability to dedust different tablet presses with one filter system without product cross-contamination; and integrated weighing systems to provide records of the quantities that have been extracted. The system can be used with coating pans, dedusters, granulating systems, tablet presses, or any other equipment and in any production environment.

Fette America
Rockaway, NJ
www.fetteamerica.com

Online ordering of replacement filters

Filtco, a leader in fume filtration and containment, has announced the availability of online ordering of replacement filters, making it easier to maintain hoods with the company’s brand replacement filters. Models are available for use in hoods made by Air Science, Astec, Captair Equipment (Bigneat and Crumair), Misonix Equipment (Labcaire), ESCO, and Semper. The online store is located at www.filtcofilters.com, and features: super activated carbon filters, HEPA, and pre-filters for all major manufacturers of fume hoods and forensic products; discounted online prices; short delivery time; guarantee of performance and quality; two easy ways to shop for filters-by the equipment you have, or by part number; payment accepted in various currencies (EUR, GPB, USD); shipping from locations in Europe and United States to reduce shipping costs; and the remaining balance of any factory warranty on your hood will be honored.

Filtco Filters
Fort Myers, FL
www.filtcofilters.com

DUV zoom lens for defect analysis

Click here to enlarge image

In response to shrinking feature sizes on semiconductor wafers, data storage devices, and microelectronic components, Navitar has released its NanoVue 248 nm 4X Deep UV Zoom lens. The system works in the deep ultraviolet (DUV) light, enabling detection and characterization of yield-critical defects while effectively doubling the resolution limit of conventional visible light microscopes. The NanoVue Zoom lens is ideal for original equipment manufacturers’ (OEM) new product development and integration into DUV instruments requiring higher throughput. The lens is designed to work with 248 nm DUV infinity-corrected microscope objectives to enable optical inspection to under 0.1 micron and has a zoom range of 0.75X to 3X. When using the 100X objective corrected at 200 mm tube length, a zoom range of 75X to 300X is possible. The field of view (FOV) of 0.14 to 0.37 mm can be achieved when using a 100X infinity corrected DUV objective with a 2/3-inch format sensor. With 0.1 micron resolution, the NanoVue is designed for the highest resolution applications. An optional motorized version speeds the observation process and automation of critical image data acquisition. The small and flexible optical footprint enables a broad range of inspection and defect review tasks including: DUV reticle and photomask inspection; thin film measurement; wafer inspection; CD metrology; failure analysis; and process control.

Navitar
Rochester, NY
www.navitar.com

Thermocouple assembly for high-purity systems

Click here to enlarge image

The Partek division of Parker Hannifin offers a new thermocouple assembly design that provides a reliable temperature monitoring sensor for high-purity fluid systems that traditionally use fluoropolymer components. Designated the TS Series, the assembly has been designed as an alternative to sensors for high-purity flow systems that are fabricated by bonding the thermocouple wires between fluoropolymer tubing elements, which can damage the wires’ insulation, creating a wicking path for the flow media that leads to eventual failure of the wiring. The probe is specially designed to fit into Partek’s new TS Series sensor. The tip itself is also sealed with fluoropolymer for protection and long life, and has minimal dead space and entrapment areas. A TS Series sensor can be specified with either a K- or J-type thermocouple probe. Mounting for the sensor is provided in the form of a compact T-shaped PFA fitting that can be installed into fluid lines to function as a straight union or a 90-degree elbow joint. The sensor element is installed into one leg of the T assembly, using a standard PFA compression ferrule set. The thermocouple is available for five tubing diameter sizes from 1/4 to 1 inch, or in a ‘jump size converter’ configuration. The thermocouple is suitable wherever accurate, low-latency temperature monitoring is required in fluoropolymer-based fluid systems.

Parker Hannifin, Partek Division
Tucson, AZ
www.parker.com/partek

Ergonomic fume hood

Click here to enlarge image

Esco’s new Basic Fume Hood (model EFB-4AX) features combined single-wall/double-wall construction and sloped 8-degree work front, offering improved operator safety and ergonomics and simplified installation of service fixtures on the front panel. Other features include: standard vertical rising fail-safe counterbalanced sash; all metal construction; and it can be shipped unassembled to save storage space and reduce costly freight charges. Standard service fixture includes: 1 water outlet, 1 gas outlet and 2 electrical outlets, and it can be supplied with no worktop for easy adaptability to any work surface. In addition, the EFB has been independently tested and certified according to ASHRAE110 protocols. A full ASHRAE110 test report and certificate are available for download.

Esco Micro Pte. Ltd.
Singapore
www.escoglobal.com

Clear PVC hose

Click here to enlarge image

The Flexaust Company, Inc. has introduced a line of clear PVC reinforced hose for a wide range of air movement, duct cleaning, and fume control applications. Flexadux® ADC is a medium weight PVC hose that is reinforced with a spring steel-wire helix and features a smooth inner surface to minimize friction loss and enhance airflow characteristics. Suitable for a variety of positive pressure and light vacuum applications, it has a wide pitch with a 9:1 compression ratio for tight bending and easy storage. Offered in sizes from 4 inches to 18 inches I.D. and standard 25-foot lengths, the hose can be supplied with a variety of accessories including clamps and J-lock connectors to permit quick connections in portable applications. Manufactured with FDA acceptable materials, this clear PVC hose operates over a 20°F to 160°F range and resists chemicals, weathering, and moisture.

The Flexaust Company, Inc.
Warsaw, IN
www.flexaust.com

Non-conductive filters

Click here to enlarge image

Universal Air Filter has introduced its non-conductive filters, for applications where space is limited and the filter frame may contact electrically charged surfaces or backplanes. The company’s non-conductive Flex-Frame filters feature flame-retardant, polypropylene plastic designed to meet the stringent filtration and flammability requirements of Telcordia NEBS, CE and UL. The non-conductive, flexing design fits ever-shrinking equipment footprints and is ideal in applications that demand that filters “snake” around components or conform to a radius-type bezel or a curved track. Flex-Frame filters are available with Quadrafoam filter media in various pore sizes: 20 through 45 PPI (green), and 10 through 60 PPI (gray or black). A solvent-resistant, two-part bonding material unites frame and filter media, making them inseparable.

Universal Air Filter Co.
Sauget, IL
www.uaf.com

Reinforced silicone hose

Click here to enlarge image

AdvantaPure, the sanitary products division of tubing-and-hose manufacturer NewAge Industries, has released its flexible braid-reinforced, platinum-cured silicone hose with a new treatment for the hose ends. Called APSH, the hose is now available with anti-wick seals to prevent liquid absorption within the hose walls, which is particularly important in industries such as pharmaceutical, bioprocess, food and beverage, chemical, and other clean applications. In addition to its anti-wick seal option, APSH is available with color-tracer braid in red, blue, yellow, green and purple and in a white-color, double-braid style for added durability. AdvantaPure manufactures all variations of APSH in HEPA-filtered cleanrooms, with key emphasis on cleanliness and validations. The hose is made from low-volatile-grade, platinum-cured silicone with braided polyester yarn between the hose walls to enhance its pressure and light-duty vacuum capabilities. It has undergone physical, chemical, and biological testing and meets USP Class VI, FDA CFR 177.2600, ISO 10993, European Pharmacopeia 3.1.9, and 3-A standards. APSH hose is suitable for either fluid or air transfer in a wide range of temperatures: -100°F to +400°F (-73°C to +204°C). It resists compression set, chemical attack, ozone, radiation, moisture, environmental exposure, and imparts no taste or odor to critical streams. It’s documented lot traceable with identification on bags and boxes and offers documented quality control as well. APSH may be sterilized by autoclave, SIP, CIP, or gamma radiation.

AdvantaPure, a division of NewAge Industries, Inc.
Southampton, PA
www.advantapure.com

Cleanroom mop system

Click here to enlarge image

The Superior Cleanroom Wall Mop System from Superior Cleanroom Products provides effective and efficient cleaning of cleanroom walls and ceilings. The mop system incorporates a stainless-steel handle and holder, with a disposable wall-washing mop head comprising lint-free polyknit polyester wiping material laminated to an inner core of highly absorbent foam. The mop system is highly resistant to strong chemicals, and is available in a range of sizes.

Superior Cleanroom Products
Galway, Ireland
www.superior.ie

Endoscope disinfection system

The new EvoTech™ Endoscope Cleaner and Reprocessor (ECR) from Advanced Sterilization Products, a Johnson & Johnson Company, is a washer/disinfection system designed to eliminate labor-intensive manual cleaning of endoscopes. Recently cleared by the FDA, it’s the first and only such system in the U.S. that establishes a consistently high standard of automated endoscope cleaning comparable to professional society guidelines for manual cleaning. The EvoTech ECR is indicated for use with high-level disinfectant CIDEX® OPA Concentrate and an enzymatic detergent (CIDEZYME GI) to achieve cleaning and high-level disinfection of heat-sensitive (>60°C), semicritical endoscopes. Manual cleaning of endoscopes is not required prior to placement in the EvoTech System when selecting those cycles that contain a wash stage. (Manual cleaning is required when selecting the “disinfect only” or “disinfect/alcohol flush” cycle.) EvoTech ECR will be available for purchase in the first half of 2007.

Advanced Sterilization Products, a Johnson & Johnson Company
Irvine, CA
www.cidex.com

Manual motor, fan controls

The B-Series VariPhase from AirCare Automation enables manual control of single-phase AC PSC motors and fans, and offers high-end features in an easy-to-use/install package. The internal microprocessor provides control of motor speed over a wide range, improving efficiency and adjustment accuracy. A user-selectable soft-start feature eliminates high-startup currents often found in AC induction motors. A minimum-speed-pot setting keeps motors/fans out of stall-current mode. VariPhase B-Series controls can be installed with shaded-pole or PSC motors. Other features include: 3-wire configuration to reduce humming noise; on/off switch that keeps existing speed setting; LED faceplate that notifies user of speed change; digital control for linear speed change; and easy wall-mount installation.

AirCare Automation, Inc.
Flushing, NY
www.aircareautomation.com

Transport pallet

Click here to enlarge image

The Aero-Pallet from AeroGo, Inc. provides nearly frictionless, horizontal omnidirectional movement to easily move and position heavy loads (1 to 14 tons). It is suitable for manufacturing and assembly applications, transporting in cleanroom environments, and moving finished products to shipping, storage and testing areas. Features include quiet operation, no emissions and vibrationless movement.

AeroGo, Inc.
Seattle, WA
www.aerogo.com

Air monitor for isolators

Click here to enlarge image

International pbi has introduced its SAS Isolator for simplified microbiological air monitoring of isolators and restricted areas. It features a stainless-steel sampling chamber that is separate from the operation unit of the air sampler, connected by a small cable to avoid bulky air tubing. The compact stainless-steel aspirating chamber can be positioned or suspended in any convenient place inside the isolator and is sterilized by VHP, with the operation unit outside. The operation unit can be connected to a printer or computer to record all sampling data. Routine calibration can be performed inside the isolator using the digital Pyramid anemometer.

International pbi S.p.A
Milan, Italy
www.internationalpbi.it

New Literature

Click here to enlarge image

Components catalog
Qosina, a leading provider of stock and custom-made components including USP Class VI tubing, filters, hemostasis valves, plastisol connectors, swabs, applicators and more, announces the release of its 568-page catalog featuring thousands of OEM disposable components. The 2007 edition contains full-size color photos of all Qosina products, including over 550 new parts, on a handy one-centimeter grid for accurate sizing. The Qosina catalog is a useful resource for engineers, product designers and purchasing departments. It also offers an expanded section for laboratory products as well as packaging items, such as dispenser tip bottles, QosiPET™ vials and droppers, and syringes. To receive a copy of the 2007 catalog, call a Customer Specialist at (631) 242-3000 or send an email to [email protected].

Qosina Corporation
Edgewood, N.Y.
www.qosina.com

Safety and protection products catalog

Click here to enlarge image

The 2007-2008 Cole-Parmer® General Catalog has 2,600 pages with more than 60,000 products-including 11,000 new items. The company’s innovative facility safety and personal protection product lines feature environmental monitoring instrumentation, protective apparel, spill control equipment, and more. All sales are backed by free applications assistance for the life of the product. To reserve a free catalog, call (800) 323-4340 or visit www.coleparmer.com/2010.

Cole-Parmer
Vernon Hills, Ill.
www.coleparmer.com

Cleanroom apparel catalog

Superior Uniform Group recently launched its new Worklon® catalog featuring cleanroom and controlled environment apparel and accessories for particle control, electrostatic dissipation, fluid resistance and bacteria filtration. ESD Lab Wear is offered in a variety of fabrics and styles. To view the new catalog, visit the company’s Web site.

Superior Uniform Group
Seminole, FL
www.superioruniformgroup.com

Fluid sensors catalog

Click here to enlarge image

The Fluid Sensors and Diagnostic Systems 2006/2007 free catalog from ifm efector offers over 400 product solutions for process control applications. The easy-to-use, 415-page catalog features the following product lines: pressure and vacuum sensors; flow sensors; level sensors; temperature sensors; condition monitoring sensors; actuator sensors; power supplies; and wiring solutions. Products are organized by intended environment, including industrial automation, sanitary and hazardous applications. To order a free catalog, visit the company’s Web site.

ifm efector inc.
Exton, PA
www.ifmefector.com

Measuring, control instruments catalog

Dwyer Instruments, Inc., producer of a broad range of measuring and control instruments for pressure, temperature, level, flow and other related applications, has released its 2007 catalog, featuring a wide range of practical and affordable instrumentation in a convenient, easy-to-use format. Product ordering information is complete and includes schedules for discounts. Orders can also be placed, checked and tracked from Dwyer’s Web site. Inventories are stocked in factory-operated warehouses in the U.S., Australia and the United Kingdom. Representatives and distributors in 60 countries assure worldwide availability. To order a free catalog or for more information, visit the company’s Web site.

Dwyer Instruments, Inc.
Michigan City, IN
www.dwyer-inst.com

Labels catalog

Click here to enlarge image

Computer Imprintable Label Systems LLC (CILS) has launched its new direct-order catalog and Web site featuring over 10,000 durable laboratory label products. A wide range of high-specification, customized and stock labels suitable for laser, thermal transfer, inkjet printing and handwriting are available. All labels are manufactured by CILS and are supplied in economical pack quantities or convenient booklets for slides, tubes, vials, plates, bottles, glassware and more. The new catalog and Web site enable fast and easy ordering with same-day online quotations for customized labels. To request a copy of the catalog, visit the company’s Web site.

Computer Imprintable Label Systems LLC
Beverly, MA
www.cils-international.com

Where sterility is neither required nor assured, procedural safeguards and effective preservative agents are key to limiting microbial contamination and proliferation

By Bruce Flickinger

For many “conventional” cosmetics and personal care products, regulatory scrutiny varies. Companies operating in this sector are GMP-regulated, but many of their products are made, labeled and sold in a regulatory gray area that avoids the intense scrutiny warranted by drugs and medical devices.

Safety concerns notwithstanding, someone has to formulate and manufacture these products, and new ingredients can be problematic for formulators, sanitarians and microbiologists alike. Given that sunscreen products alone are a roughly $400 million annual business in the U.S., many players are involved and working to devise more efficient, less expensive means of making them. Indeed, much of the cosmetics and personal care industry today can be characterized by the continual search for interesting products, novel functionalities, and beauty- and health-enhancing claims that often blur the line between cosmetics and pharmaceuticals.

Charles Haywood, president of Mansfield-King, a contract cosmetics and personal care products manufacturer based in Indianapolis, IN, puts it this way: “We try to stay active doing some formulation development work with some of the smaller players because you never know if they’re going to have the next big thing.”

Mansfield-King produces over-the-counter (OTC) and non-OTC products, both for private label and on contract, with about 60 percent of its business in traditional hair and body care. Haywood acknowledges that some new “cosmeceutical” formulations require additional formulation expertise and a broad, deep stability testing program before going to market, simply because some of the chemistries do not have the track record of more traditional products. “Quality assurance is essentially the same, but requires an understanding that challenges are more likely to arise [with these] than with more traditional products,” Haywood says.

Still, “most of the industry’s processes are well characterized, and the regulations are understood,” Haywood says. “The challenge is staying in continuous compliance and staying focused on what FDA is looking for, how they’re interpreting certain parts of the regulations or developing a new OTC monograph. These things are constantly changing.”

Life finds a way

FDA defines the term “cosmetic” as something intended to be rubbed, poured, sprinkled, or sprayed on, introduced into, or otherwise applied to the human body for cleansing, beautifying, promoting attractiveness, or altering the appearance. The definition also encompasses the individual ingredients or components of these products, but does not include soap.

A cosmetic can be deemed adulterated under section 601 of the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act for four reasons: it can be injurious to users under conditions of customary use because it contains, or its container is composed of, a potentially harmful substance; it contains filth; it contains a non-permitted or non-certified color additive; or it is manufactured or held under unsanitary conditions whereby it may have become injurious to users or contaminated with filth.

With regard to ingredients, there is a standard stock of materials that are generally well characterized and used in varying combinations and strengths in a range of products. These include surfactants, colorants, binders, preservatives and active ingredients, the safety of which is monitored by the Cosmetic Ingredient Review, a panel of doctors and scientists from industry and government. The group reviews and assesses the safety of ingredients used in cosmetics in an open, unbiased manner, and publishes the results in peer-reviewed scientific literature, notably the International Journal of Toxicology.

In addition to potential negative impact on human health, ingredients can act as a contamination source in the processing plant. Surfactants can be particularly problematic in terms of introducing unwanted organisms into the process. Things can “go awry” with these materials, even with surfactants that typically are hostile to bacteria, says Daniel Brannan, PhD, a professor of biology at Abilene Christian University in Abilene, TX, and co-editor of Cosmetic Microbiology: A Practical Handbook, now in its second edition.

“Always remember that life finds a way,” Brannan says. “Bacteria are always adapting and evolving, so what is effective today might not be tomorrow.”

Continual vigilance and a good relationship with surfactant suppliers are critical. “Ensure that your supplier knows what they’re doing microbiologically,” Brannan says. “Make sure they know that the preservative is chemically compatible and works in the surfactant, and [that they] know how to manufacture the product in a sanitary manner.” It is also advisable to audit the surfactant plant to see how committed the company is to GMPs.

“Most of the time, bacterial problems occur because people think of microbes as if they are a chemical anomaly,” Brannan continues. “But it’s not like fixing a pH problem or any other manufacturing issue. These are living, adapting, changing biological entities that are very versatile in their ability to contaminate.”

Brannan’s work as an on-site consultant and troubleshooter for cosmetics companies, unfortunately, echoes the experiences of many: “They call me in when they’re in trouble,” he says. His consulting work involves a “thorough education” comprising one day of lecturing on industrial microbiology and one day auditing the plant. Brannan and his colleague, Phil Geis, also present an annual course on cosmetic microbiology through the Center for Professional Advancement.


Figure 1. Typical cleaning test methods might include microorganism detection through swabbing and plating, as well as examination of surfaces with an ATP bioluminescence meter (shown). Photo courtesy of Hardy Diagnostics.
Click here to enlarge image

“I require that everyone in the plant be present, all the way up to the president,” he says. “And they had better be committed: When they balk at seemingly innocuous things like cleaning the dust off the rafters or cleaning out their floor drains, then they’re doomed to repeat their mistakes. I cannot over-emphasize how important it is to get the people in the plant educated about basic microbiology.”

Water and other culprits

From both regulatory and common sense perspectives, cosmetics need not be sterile, but they must not be contaminated with microorganisms that may be pathogenic. The density of non-pathogenic microorganisms should be low. In addition, cosmetics should remain in this condition when used by consumers, which is a tall order, given the handling that takes place and the demands that are placed on some of these products-consider, for example, a half-gallon bottle of soap or shampoo that has to withstand repeated openings over several weeks in a hot, humid bathtub or shower stall. Other products, notably those containing more than 10 percent ethanol, propylene glycol or glycerol, and those in self-pressurized containers, usually are self-preserving and are not likely to become contaminated with microorganisms.

“Reducing microbial contamination is about building quality into every step of the process,” Haywood says. “Each step has to be broken down into its components and analyzed for possible problems. Then best practices have to be encapsulated in SOPs to minimize the risk of contamination, and to catch any contamination sources before they cause a problem in a product.” Cleaning and sanitizing SOPs should be designed to reduce microbial contamination to preset acceptable levels, and to ensure that conditions favorable for microbial growth are avoided. Therefore, each product and formulation typically require an examination as to what cleaning and sanitizing is necessary.


Figure 2. Although people and incoming raw materials are important sources of microbiological contamination, Professor Daniel Brannan says water is the primary offender. He recommends replacing water softeners and charcoal filtration systems with reverse osmosis systems (shown). Photo courtesy of Christ Water Technology.
Click here to enlarge image

“Most ‘standard’ products, such as basic shampoos and lotions, require similar cleaning and sanitizing of manufacturing and packaging equipment, but cleaning validation should be performed for each cleaning/sanitizing method,” Haywood says. “Analytically, this means establishing a cleaning validation protocol, which includes acceptance and rejection standards as well as test methods, and the following of that protocol by the quality control unit to determine test results.” Typical methods at Mansfield-King include specified microorganism detection through swabbing and plating, as well as examination of surfaces with an ATP bioluminescence meter (see Fig. 1).

The goal, obviously, is keeping bacteria out of the plant, and effectively limiting the growth and proliferation of those organisms that inevitably find their way in. Typical safeguards include the use of a vacuum to prevent blowing or splattering of powders, and sneeze guards and dust covers to protect fill lines, filler heads and mixing tanks. Plants obviously should be kept scrupulously clean, and floors kept clear of product or water spills. In microbiological testing laboratories, a laminar airflow hood is sometimes used in the preparation of media for testing. Unlike manufacturers of pharmaceuticals, however, cosmetics manufacturers are prohibited from using toxic ingredients, so laminar flow hoods typically are not required in the manufacturing environment.

Although people and incoming raw materials are important sources of microbiological contamination, Brannan says unequivocally that water is the primary offender. “Even chlorinated city water is loaded with pseudomonads of all types, which are not eliminated very effectively by the usual treatments of charcoal or carbon filtration and water-softening processes,” he says. “The hundreds of bacteria per mL coming into a plant can blossom into tens of thousands per mL in the process water.”


Figure 3. The MicroSeq is used to identify organisms in raw products and excipients, and in preservative testing and environmental monitoring protocols. Photo courtesy of Applied Biosystems.
Click here to enlarge image

Brannan advises replacing water softeners and charcoal filtration systems with reverse osmosis systems (see Fig. 2), “all stainless 316 and all heated to 180°F for a half-hour at least once per week with a continuous circulation of water kept no lower than 140°F at all times until right before batching.” Process water can be cooled before batching using validated heat exchangers. Regarding this approach, “The biggest complaint I get from plant people is about the costs involved, but think about how much a recall would cost the company,” Brannan says. “Spend the money on a good water system. Period.”

Similarly, another good “fallback position” that Brannan recommends is to always have storage tanks for liquid raw materials that can be heated to at least 120°F and kept at that temperature for at least 24 hours. Options include heating materials to 180°F for a half-hour, 160°F for 4 hours, 140°F for 12 hours or 120°F for 24 hours. “This way, you can take surfactant from the supplier, place it into the heated tank and keep the bugs from ever adapting,” Brannan says.

Ensuring antimicrobial activity

In addition to sanitary storage and handling of raw materials and sanitary manufacture of finished products, FDA’s GMPs for cosmetic manufacture stipulate that each batch of a cosmetic that is not self-preserving be tested for microbial contamination before it is released and each product, particularly eye-area cosmetics, be tested during product development for adequacy of preservation against microbial contamination that may occur under reasonably foreseeable conditions of consumer use.

The Cosmetic, Toiletry, and Fragrance Association (CTFA) has recently published revised quality assurance and good manufacturing practice guidelines, and currently is requesting public comment on them. Called the CTFA Quality Assurance Guidelines, the publication consists of a core chapter on the principles of cosmetic GMPs and 24 supporting annexes designed to “better align the GMP standards for cosmetics with international ISO standards,” says John Bailey, executive vice president for science with CTFA.

The current draft represents a “significant revision and update of our GMP guidelines,” Bailey continues. “It is important to have international consensus on manufacturing standards, both from GMP and market perspectives, and we feel this revision has been a very positive step in bringing us up to the current state of GMPs in cosmetics.”

While core GMP principles are well understood in most countries, terminology issues had to be addressed and unified definitions developed in the use of sanitization versus disinfection, or facilities versus premises, for example. Process waste is also handled differently in different GMP structures. Bailey adds, “One important area is defining responsibilities in contract manufacturing arrangements. We focused a lot of attention here.”

“We carry out identification, attribute and microorganism tests” at raw material, in-process and finished product stages, Haywood says. “Naturally, the analytical method varies depending on the testing specifications set forth in the SOPs. Identification is carried out using gas chromatography (GC) or high-pressure liquid chromatography (HPLC), typically according to USP monographs. Other attribute tests (such as melting point) are also done for identification, and in-process and finished-product testing includes viscosity, specific gravity and pH.

Testing the efficacy of preservative systems is perhaps the most important component of the cosmetics manufacturer’s testing regimen. When preservatives are used, the goal is to add only as much as is needed to the formulation; laboratories must be careful to blend the right amount of preservative with ingredients to kill bacteria without triggering allergic reactions in consumers. Also, preservatives can react with a cosmetic’s own active ingredients, causing skin irritations or rashes.

The USP 51 Antimicrobial Effectiveness Test is the industry standard for evaluating either intrinsic antimicrobial properties or different types and levels of added antimicrobial agents. In the protocol, inoculated microorganisms (Candida albicans, Aspergillus niger, Escherichia coli, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, and Staphylococcus aureus) are added directly to the test product at relatively high concentrations to simulate contamination. The product is held for one month, during which time the added microorganisms are enumerated weekly to determine whether they are growing, dying off, or remaining near the initial inoculation level. The key to an accurate test is having fresh, active cultures standardized to a concentration that, when added to the product, deliver between 100,000 to 1,000,000 cells per mL of the test product.

The acceptance criteria for antimicrobial effectiveness is described in detail in USP 51, but generally, a 1 to 3 log reduction in bacteria from the initial level should occur in one to two weeks, with no further increase in bacteria after two weeks. For yeast and mold, no increase from the initial inoculum level is permitted.

Parabens, such as methyl-, propyl- and butylparaben, are among the most commonly used preservatives in cosmetics products. Because they generally make up less than 1 percent of a total product formulation, parabens are considered safe by most manufacturers and ingredients specialists. However, an increasing number of natural personal care companies are moving away from parabens and using food-grade preservatives such as sodium benzoate, potassium sorbate and grapefruit seed extract. Other companies rely on the preservative properties inherent in other ingredients, such as essential oils and vitamin E, sanitary manufacturing, complicated pH balancing formulas, and packaging that is designed to keep bacteria, yeast and mold from contaminating the products.

Observers are generally of the opinion that, while natural ingredients might allow a company to make some rather spurious label claims, they do nothing but complicate the formulation and processing of the product.

“Natural products are most vulnerable to lapses in quality assurance or microbial control,” Haywood says. “Because natural preservatives are typically less robust than traditional preservatives, we emphasize to customers with natural products the need for extensive preservative efficacy testing before going to market, particularly for products that are likely to be challenged by consumer use.”

Adds Brannan, “The biggest issue with natural materials is that they just do not work or add real testable value to the product. One thing they do, however, is compromise the preservatives in the products and become food that promotes bacterial growth.”

Modern methods

Along with preservative testing, microbial identification is also important for pinpointing particular strains and their sources in order to eliminate these problems. Genotypic techniques are gaining adherents for their speed and accuracy, including FDA: In a 2004 cGMP guidance, the agency indicated that genotypic methods were more accurate and reliable than traditional biochemical and phenotypic methods.

One DNA sequencing system that’s finding traction in the cosmetics industry is the MicroSeq (see Fig. 3) from Applied Biosystems (Foster City, CA). The system is used to identify organisms in raw products and excipients, and in preservative testing and environmental monitoring protocols. “The analysis is very fast-from a colony on a plate to an identification in less than five hours,” says James Bruce, product manager with the Applied Biosystems Quality and Safety Testing Group. “It is well suited to QC laboratories running high volumes of routine tests.”

Unlike growth-based methods, the MicroSeq can help manufacturers positively identify and classify even new and previously uncharacterized bacteria and fungi because the system uses PCR-based sequencing methods to rapidly amplify and organize DNA sequences. The sequences are compared to a validated library for positive identification and taxonomic classifications. The technique “provides a high level of accuracy, because the DNA is not impacted by background organisms, by organisms affected or sublethally injured by preservatives, or by changes in antimicrobial resistance in the target organism,” Bruce says.

“Cosmetic microbiology is evolving quickly, and new technologies are being adopted steadily,” Bruce adds. While Mansfield-King outsources its preservative efficacy testing to avoid having pathogenic and other microorganisms in its facility, Haywood concurs, “New analytical techniques are frequently introduced; we keep an open mind regarding new techniques, particularly where possible increases in speed may result.”

Regarding outsourcing of testing, Brannan says this clearly is the best option when the necessary expertise is not in-house, but this is often a stopgap measure. In Brannan’s experience, outsourcing is typically equated with “putting out fires,” and “no one wants to hear bad news from an outside source, let alone their own people. Production out the door usually wins out over quality.”

A better option? “Invest in an in-house microbiology lab,” Brannan suggests. “Hire a good industrial microbiologist and give him a real voice in the decision-making process. Hire an appropriate number of technicians to do the day-to-day testing work.”

Speaking from the other side of the outsourcing equation, Haywood says “communication about a company’s focus on quality is a distinguishing factor for contract manufacturers. If clients and potential clients are aware of a company’s focus, they are more likely to be comfortable, and more likely to choose a company that they perceive has a keen focus on quality. We certainly find that our focus on quality is something our client base desires and appreciates, just as much as they desire and appreciate timeliness, responsiveness and a good price.”

Although significant progress has been made by the industry toward implementation of sanitary manufacturing practices, more rigorous microbiological control, and the development of better-preserved cosmetic products, the problem of adequacy of preservation of cosmetics to prevent contamination during both processing and consumer use continues to be of concern to both industry and regulators. For a traditional industrial microbiologist like Brennan, the key is for a company to make the connection between the microbiological health of a plant and integrity of the product.

“Usually you have to wait until a company has a recall or returned product to get their attention,” Brannan says. “Companies might go years without a problem, and then a recall or returned product will remind them how important sanitation and microbiological control are. It’s more important to have quality going out the door than product going out the door.”

Much still to be done


December 1, 2006

The contamination control industry has accomplished much over the last few decades, and there is much to take pride in. Certainly among these accomplishments is the development and introduction of a host of new technology solutions and contamination control products for a number of user industries. However, now is not the time for the industry to rest on its laurels.

One of the greatest contributions that the contamination control profession has made to the industries it serves is education and training. Without having first educated the early-user communities (nuclear, microelectronics, aerospace, pharmaceuticals) regarding the consequences of poor contamination control practices, procedures and protocols, and the great benefits available through the implementation of new tools and systems, none of the industries that now embrace the technology would have seen how valuable it is. Similarly today, there are many other professions that are still largely unaware of the capabilities and advantages offered by a thorough understanding of the proper implementation of contamination control technology and practices.

One such major opportunity exists in the community of compounding pharmacists. Though some pharmacists are already well underway with the process of fully meeting new contamination control requirements in their practices, many others are resistant, largely due to a lack of knowledge about already-existing solutions or unrealistic fears of insurmountable up-front cost obstacles. Both groups can benefit from the experience and knowledge of contamination control professionals. No technology or product will be of use to this community if they do not first understand the impact and criticality of efficient contamination control itself.

Similarly, hospital hygiene across the board entails reaching an entirely new universe of healthcare professionals. Not one single death from hospital-acquired infection should be acceptable, let alone the thousands that occur annually in the U.S. alone. Once again, education is the first step toward driving new initiatives and implementations of contamination control science in an environment critical to us all.

Clearly, the food industry must also become better educated in contamination control and what is truly required to achieve complete and reliable results. Quality control is not contamination control. Cleaning and sanitation practices are not contamination control. It’s time for the food industry to step out of the past and into the real world of modern contamination control science and technology.

Overall, our industry must continue to reach out to offer education, training and support to forward-thinking advocates and early-adopters of contamination control science-on both the industry and regulatory sides.

John Haystead, Editor-in-Chief

To make the most efficient lighting selection, know your requirements and your options

By Robert Catone, Guth Lighting

Although the lighting field has seen many technological improvements over the last decade, many challenges remain for design teams working to specify the best technology systems for environmentally controlled environments. The biggest challenge is that there are no formal standards for cleanroom lighting, largely leaving the selection process up to whatever the specifier deems to be important and sufficient.

There are, however, a great number of clean-space standards that have a direct impact on proper lighting selection and installation, the most widely recognized being ISO 14644-1, which establishes the acceptable levels of particulates for various classes of cleanrooms. And, there are a great number of regulatory and inspection agencies-such as the FDA for the pharmaceutical and biopharmaceutical industries-that monitor and evaluate the cleanliness levels of lighting fixtures.

In the food industry, there are nine broad categories of processes (poultry, dairy, bakery, confectionary, meat, beverage, fish, vegetables and prepared foods), and there are numerous regulatory agencies (FDA, OSHA, USDA) that inspect for sanitation and safety. At the lighting equipment manufacturing level, the National Sanitation Foundation (NSF) International certifies fixtures for use in food-contact and splash-zone areas.

As a result, cleanroom and clean environment contractors and users need to have a thorough understanding of the different types of lighting, lighting fixture and installation options available.

Lamps

The best place to start is with an evaluation of the different types of lighting available for clean spaces. The most common lamps for areas below 10 feet are linear and compact fluorescent, with metal halide lamps reserved for higher mountings.

Among the most important factors to consider is lamp lifetime, taking into account not only the initial cost of the lamp but the cost to replace it. For example, in some cleanrooms, the relamping of a fixture may require recertification of the entire cleanroom because the fixtures have been opened up. This is why the new 40K-hour lamps are of particular interest in the cleanroom industry, providing eight years of lighting without having to change a bulb, and most users are happy to pay an additional $2 to $3 for the lamp.

Lamp lifetime is largely a function of the type of phosphor used. Lower grade phosphors, such as those used in F32T8-741 type lamps, equate to a cost of about $1.25/lamp but have a much shorter lifetime than the F32T8-XXL, which costs about $3.50/lamp but has a 40K-hour lifetime (see Table 1).

Color accuracy is also dependent on the type of phosphor used, with some of the newer phosphors providing much better color accuracy. In the table of linear fluorescent lamps, 82.5 is the lowest performance with the highest being 91.4. This relates to the relative color accuracy compared to incandescent lamps, which are rated at 100. Some specialized lamps can achieve accuracies as high as 95 percent, which is an important factor for some applications such as food processing where vegetable color in an inspection line is critical. Superior color accuracy can also be an important aesthetic factor for some architects. For most applications, however, color accuracy above 80 is adequate given the average ability of most individuals to discern differences.

Lamp types

There are several different lamp types available with varying performance characteristics to suit a range of applications.


Table 1: Performance characteristics of linear fluorescent lamps
Click here to enlarge image

Linear fluorescent
These four-foot-length tubular lamps are available in varying levels of quality and performance, with the one-inch diameter T8 having replaced the T-12 as the standard. The metric 46” T5HO lamp is also being used with some exotic fixtures. These lamps operate best between 0°F and 85°F. Table 1 shows the performance characteristics of different linear fluorescent lamps.


Table 2: Performance characteristics of compact fluorescent lamps
Click here to enlarge image

Compact fluorescent
These 4- to 11-inch lamps have become popular in down-lights and small architectural fixtures. In some cases, multiple lamps allow stepped light levels and energy management. They are replacing low-wattage metal halide in many applications. The starting temperature can be as low as -22°F. Lumen output is stable up to 140°F (see Table 2).


Table 3: Metal halide performance with electronic ballasts
Click here to enlarge image

Metal halide
Metal halide lamps provide white light and are unaffected by temperature. Their starting temperature can be as low as -20°F. Lamp re-strike can take 2 to 6 minutes after a power outage. These lamps are used from 10 to 40 feet (see Table 3).

Specialty lamps, coatings and sleeves
In addition to the more commonly used lamp types described above, there are also a number of specialty lamps available offering unique features and capabilities. For example, induction lamps are an expensive fluorescent system operated by microwave energy. These lamps provide 100,000 hours of life and are available from 60 to 165 watts. They are particularly useful in cases where maintenance is expensive.

Another example is special color spectrum lamps, which have tinted sleeves or lenses to control UV or provide special colors for animal environments or custom applications. Break-proof lamps are available from coating companies and some manufacturers. Teflon is generally used to contain the broken glass.

Another option, light emitting diodes (LEDs) can provide 50,000 hours of life when properly heat sunk. These systems are expensive, however, and white-light efficiency is about 35 percent that of fluorescent lamps. It is the primary lamp for signage and exit lights.

Electronic ballasts

Electronic ballasts are the standard for fluorescent lamps and are also quickly becoming the standard for metal halide lamps as well (see Fig. 1). New, high, 1.3-ballast-factor designs increase T8 fluorescent lumens per lamp up to 35 percent. Since ballast life is shortened when case temperatures are at their limits, manufacturers also offer premium higher-temperature versions. Daylight harvesting, load shedding and automatic dimming features have all been integrated into the newer ballast designs, providing the following standard and optional benefits: efficient lamp performance, quiet operation, integral dimming or step dimming, end of life lamp shut-off, computer software control, self protection against overheating, universal voltage and lamp operation, small size and minimal weight, and higher T8 lumen per lamp electronics.

Fixtures

The next important factor to consider in cleanroom or clean-environment lighting selection is the type of fixture to be used. Again, cost can be a determinant. In general, stainless steel is the most expensive fixture material available, with aluminum falling somewhere in the middle range and painted steel being the cheapest. Aluminum housings provide the coolest electronic ballast and lamp operation, while stainless-steel housings operate hottest.


Figure 1. These electronic ballasts provide state-of-the-art operation for fluorescent and metal halide lamps. Photo courtesy of Advance Transformer
Click here to enlarge image

Maintenance, lifetime and replacement costs should also be taken into account in addition to initial fixture prices. For example, many food and pharmaceutical plants will initially opt for cheaper, painted-steel fixtures only to find that after repeated wash-downs, the paint begins to flake or peel and the steel to rust, requiring replacement. It’s often just a question of whose budget will absorb these costs, and the individual responsible for the initial construction budget may opt for the cheaper steel fixtures without consideration to the person responsible for maintenance, whose budget will ultimately be affected.

Cleanroom class level is, of course, a critical consideration. For a Class 10,000 (ISO 7) cleanroom, fixtures are basically a standard unit with a gasket on the door. Additionally, some kind of gasket is used between the fixture and the ceiling grid system supporting it, but the fixture usually has minimal additional protection and in many cases may not be caulked.

For a Class 1,000 (ISO 6) cleanroom, however, all of the ceiling fixtures should be caulked and the fixture doors sealed as well. Some users may require that the lens also be sealed to the door frame. Still, the stringency of the installation will be largely dependent on the person writing the specification, with one person writing a spec for a Class 1,000 cleanroom that is much more stringent than someone else might write for the same class room.

The installer, as well as the fixture supplier, is also an important consideration, especially for sheetrock ceilings vs. grid systems. For example, the installer must cut openings into the sheetrock to house the fixtures. Typically, four brackets are used to hold the fixture in place, with the brackets basically torqued down against the sheetrock and the fixture sitting snugly against it. In some cases, however, the sheetrock ceiling is not perfectly flat (referred to as sag), leaving a gap between the flange of the fixture and the sheetrock. This will be a particular concern if using steel fixtures, which may weigh up to 60 lbs and will not help in maintaining the flatness of the sheetrock.

Aluminum fixtures, weighing about 16 lbs, are more forgiving but the installation contractor should still often be required to caulk the edges of the fixture. Again, it ultimately depends on the level of cleanliness that the user is interested in maintaining.

Fixture types

Recessed troffers, which come in myriad sizes, lamps, gaskets and construction types, are the primary fixture choice for many cleanroom, lab, pharmaceutical and food processing applications. Welded housings should be used with positive plenum pressure rooms. Lenses are generally installed with the smooth side out to reduce dirt accumulation, and louvers with a sealed underlay are available to lower glare in sensitive areas. HID metal halide lamps are usually available in 2’ x 2’ housings for high, insulated ceiling applications.

Surface fixtures are used when ceiling penetration is not desired, and these are available in many sizes, lamps, shapes, materials and gasketing levels to meet the most exacting requirements.

  • Teardrop fixtures maximize linear airflow in Class 100 (ISO 5) cleanrooms. Smaller designs for T8 lamps enhance airflow. Lengths are available up to 16 feet.
  • Tubes that are sealed and NSF-certified are most popular in food plants but have also found success in vivariums and Class 3 and 4 labs. A variety of lengths, stainless-steel endcaps and moveable mounting straps provide durability, amiable optics and versatility. Optical options provide task, inspection or general lighting.
  • Wraparound fixture construction can be plastic, fiberglass, aluminum and caulked or seam-welded stainless steel. Gasketing can provide dust-tight and waterproof listings. Most of these fixtures find use in food processing areas where captive latches are a requirement.
  • Lowbay fixtures with metal halide lamps are generally used above 15 feet in food facilities. Designs with smooth contours and rounded surfaces are most popular because they resist dirt build-up and clean easily.

Figure 2. Lowbays with sealed construction and prismatic lens can create an attractive aesthetic feature in a clean environment. Photo courtesy of Guth Lighting.
Click here to enlarge image

Architectural fixtures are generally used in laboratories with open ceilings. Here, enclosed construction and ease of cleaning should be a priority.

  • Lowbay fixtures use 1 to 8 compact fluorescent lamps. Customization provides accent colors that can add variety to the space. Fixtures are 12, 16 or 22 inches in diameter and may have sealed or open optics (see Fig. 2).
  • Attractive wraparound and surface fixtures are available with enclosed or gasketed construction. A variety of sizes, lengths and finishes can meet most aesthetic requirements.

Cost factors

For new construction projects, lighting selection is usually not highly price sensitive because it will be relatively insignificant compared to the total cost of the building. Where it does become price sensitive, however, is on retrofits where contractors often try to use the lowest-cost option in order to increase their margins. Sometimes, the user may also wish to keep upfront costs to the bare minimum.

Advances in technology, when properly applied, provide many new ways to save energy and lower construction and maintenance costs in the cleanroom. In future, improved control systems and more efficient lamps will also continue to offer lower energy consumption and operating costs.


Robert Catone is a certified lighting professional, the general manager of Guth Lighting and VP of the JJI Lighting Group. He is a member of the Illuminating Engineering Society’s Progress Committee and credited with 2 lighting patents. Guth (www.guth.com), a division of Genlyte Corporation, was founded in 1902 and specializes in fixtures for cleanrooms, laboratories, pharmaceutical manufacturing and food processing.

The five-year review process has begun and some documents are now being revisited

By Robert L. Mielke, Abbott Laboratories, and secretary of ISO Technical Committee 209

Background
In 1993, ISO Technical Committee 209, Cleanrooms and associated controlled environments, was formally established and had its first meeting in Chicago, Illinois. Over the past 13 years there have been 18 meetings, the last of which was held in Beijing, China, in September of this year. In those 13 years a great deal has been accomplished. Eight documents have been published: ISO 14644 Parts 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7 and 8, and ISO 14698 Parts 1 and 2 (see Table 1).

Current status

The Technical Committee now has 20 countries that are voting “P” (Participating) members (see Table 2) and 21 countries that are “O” (Observing) members (see Table 3). There are also six “L” (Liaison) members consisting of four ISO Technical Committees, one CEN Technical Committee and the International Confederation of Contamination Control Societies (ICCCS), as shown in Table 4. The Technical Committee has convened nine working groups (WGs) over the years and currently has four active ones. They are WG 1, Air cleanliness; WG 6, Terms and definitions; WG 8, Chemical contamination; and WG 9, Clean surfaces.

The Technical Committee has a new chairman, David Brande, who succeeded Richard Matthews. Matthews had served as chairman for 12 years (1993-2005).

Reports

WG 1, Air cleanliness
ISO 14644-1:1999>-This document, Cleanrooms and associated controlled environments-Part 1: Classification of air cleanliness, is currently going through revision by the WG. The standard was reviewed and voted on in 2004 by the technical committee and was reaffirmed as a standard. However, at the 16th technical committee meeting in 2004 in Cologne, it was resolved to have ISO/TC 209 Working Group 1 review the document for areas within the document that might be changed and report back to the committee. A decision was made by ISO/TC 209 at the 17th technical committee meeting in 2005 in Moscow to revise Part 1. Working on the revision, WG 1 has held three meetings since the Moscow meeting.

The main issues are as follows:

  • The table for air cleanliness classifications in the normative section would become the primary method for determining air cleanliness classes and the formula would be used for intermediate classes, similar to the cancelled FED-STD-209E.
  • Also in the normative section, the working group recommends dropping the single-digit concentration numbers from the air cleanliness classification table and providing further guidance on very low (i.e., two-digit) particle concentrations. The current table suggests unreliable limits that demand very large sample volumes.
  • The graph in Informative Annex A may be improved to make it more useful.
  • The WG has discussed the method for determining the number of testing locations as discussed in Informative Annex B and at this time is inclined to leave the method unaltered unless changes in the statistical analyses would dictate otherwise.
  • A problem has been identified with the current statistical approach regarding collection and evaluation of particle count data in Informative Annexes B and C. The statistics in the standard currently assume an even concentration of particles over the area being tested (e.g., cleanroom) and this may or may not be the case. The WG is evaluating a number of methods for showing statistical relevance to the number of locations required and the minimum number of samples at each location.
  • The WG is working on improving Informative Annex F to make it easer to use. The sequential sampling technique will be retained for situations where there are very low limits and very long sample times. However, it is felt that the annex needs to be made clearer.

Currently, there is only an internal working draft of the document. When a draft is ready to be reviewed by the technical committee, a New Work Item Proposal will be generated.

ISO 14644-2:2000-This document, Cleanrooms and associated controlled environments-Part 2: Specifications for testing and monitoring to prove continued compliance with ISO 14644-1, is being revised by the WG. The standard was reviewed and voted upon in 2005 by the technical committee. The vote determined that ISO/TC 209 Working Group 1 would review the standard. WG 1 has met three times to work on the revision.

The main issues are as follows:

  • The normative section in Part 2 is felt to be confusing regarding testing and monitoring. The WG wants to improve and clarify the explanation of the link between monitoring and testing.
  • A discussion was held by the WG to determine whether the document should differentiate between testing for qualification and testing for requalification of a cleanroom.
  • The WG plans to clarify the various testing frequencies.
  • The WG plans to eliminate the current Annex B on risk assessment. It is anticipated that the subject of risk assessment will be dealt with in the normative section.
  • A new Annex B may be written to give additional guidance on testing and monitoring plans.

Table 1: ISO Technical Committee 209 published documents
Click here to enlarge image

The convener of the WG reiterated that the group needs a consistent effort from the experts in order to move forward. The WG’s next meeting will be in March 2007 and the target date for publication is January 2009. However, one of the intermediate milestones has already slipped.

Working Group 6, Terms and definitions

ISO/FDIS 14644-6-This document, Cleanrooms and associated controlled environments-Part 6: Terms and definitions, was submitted by the secretariat on August 31, 2006, to the ISO central secretariat for FDIS vote. WG 6 sees this standard as a “living document” due to the continuing systematic review and revision of the ISO/TC 209 documents as well as the new terms and definitions being created by WG 9.


Table 2: “P”(Participating) members
Click here to enlarge image

During the DIS vote process, there were several terms that were questioned by some of the P member countries. The ISO/TC 209 secretariat worked with the ISO central secretariat editor to harmonize duplicate definitions.

There was some discussion as to the value of the document due to possible future revisions; WG 6 recommended that ISO 14644-6 be approved in order to establish a starting point from which the technical committee could move forward. The role of WG 6 will continue and the group plans to be very involved in checking each revision and new document to ensure consistency in the terms and definitions.


Table 3: “O” (Observer) members
Click here to enlarge image

The technical committee resolved that the role of WG 6 should continue after the vocabulary standard is published. The vocabulary standard could be revised before the systematic review period to reflect any revisions or new terms.

Working Group 8, Clean surfaces

ISO/FDIS 14644-8-This document, Cleanrooms and associated controlled environments-Part 8: Classification of airborne molecular contamination, was published as a standard on August 15, 2006.

A discussion ensued regarding the many overlapping areas between the work of WG 8 and WG 9, making it difficult for the groups to clarify their missions. It was suggested that WG 8 focus on surface chemical contamination and WG 9 focus on surface particulate contamination. To aid in defining the mission of WG 8, it was resolved that it be renamed “Chemical contamination” to enable the technical committee to allow WG 8 to expand the mission of the group to chemical surface contamination.

Working Group 9, Clean surfaces

ISO/WD 14644-9-WG 9 is preparing its Committee Draft, which is nearly complete. The technical committee resolved that when the secretariat receives the draft, it should initiate a New Work Item Proposal (NWIP).

The technical committee requested that WG 9 produce an outline of its thoughts on what should be addressed in a standard (or part of a standard) covering the subject of cleaning of surfaces, detailed such that the technical committee would be able to determine the direction in which it would want the WG to proceed.


Table 4: “L” (Liaison) members
Click here to enlarge image

WG 9 requested that member bodies nominate experts for the development of an additional or separate standard on cleaning, as the WG feels it is lacking sufficient numbers of cleaning experts. There was also a concern over conflicts with current documents, or documents that are in preparation, regarding process cleaning. In previous meetings the technical committee had elected to not become involved in process methods. It was suggested that the WG focus on what should be accomplished in cleaning-what should or should not be done.

Additional discussion on ISO/TC 209 documents

A request was brought forward by the U.K. delegation to begin the review process on ISO 14698-1:2003, Cleanrooms and associated controlled environments-Biocontamination control-Part 1: General principles and ISO 14698-2:2003, Cleanrooms and associated controlled environments-Biocontamination control-Part 2: Evaluation and interpretation of biocontamination data, prior to the normal five-year review.

Some members of WG 2 have suggested that they begin working on the two ISO 14698 documents now, rather than wait until the documents are due for systematic review in 2008. After some discussion, the technical committee decided that the ISO/TC 209 chairman should establish an ad hoc group comprising primarily microbiologists to review the ISO 14698 Part 1 and ISO 14698 Part 2 documents to determine which issues need to be addressed and to report its findings at the next ISO/TC 209 technical committee meeting.

During the WG 9 discussion, it was suggested that there be a new focus on surface biocontamination, as the standards are missing classifications for airborne and surface microbial contamination. It was felt that this topic was better suited for review by the working group that would be working on biocontamination rather than by WG 9. The technical committee had previously mandated that the group not address the area of microbiology, but if a system could be developed that would be beneficial, then the focus could include this area. The technical committee resolved to establish an ad hoc group, comprising primarily microbiologists, to determine the issues that should be addressed. The group will report its findings at the next technical committee meeting.

Epilogue

As can be seen, although the majority of the documents being produced by ISO Technical Committee 209 have been completed, the five-year review process has begun and some of the documents are being revisited. The committee has a number of issues that it is addressing and needs input from the countries’ Technical Advisory Groups (TAG). The TAGs will need input from the user community within their countries. If you have questions about, or want to offer input into, any of the ISO 14644 and ISO 14698 documents, contact your country’s TAG. In the U.S., the TAG is administered by the Institute of Environmental Sciences and Technology (IEST). Additional information may be found at www.iest.org

Postscript

The five-year review vote on ISO 14644-4:2001-Cleanrooms and associated controlled environments-Part 4: Design, construction and start-up, was tallied after the Beijing Technical Committee meeting. The consensus was to renew the document for another five-year period.

Robert Mielke is a principal metrology engineer at Abbott Laboratories (North Chicago, IL). He has been in Abbott’s Corporate Metrology Group for fourteen years. He holds a BS from Miami University of Ohio and is a Fellow of the Institute of Environmental Sciences and Technology (IEST). Mielke served the IEST as Standards and Practices Chairman for eight years, and as Contamination Control Technical Vice President from 1995 to 1997 and 1999 to 2001 respectively. He is the secretary of ISO/TC 209 and a U.S. delegate to ISO/TC 209 Working Group 1, which wrote ISO 14644-1 and ISO 14644-2. Mielke is the chair of IEST Working Group 006. He has presented more than 30 papers and given many tutorials on topics related to contamination control.


About IEST

Founded in 1953, IEST is an international technical society of engineers, scientists, and educators that serves its members and the industries they represent (simulating, testing, controlling, and teaching the environments of earth and space) through education and the development of recommended practices and standards. IEST is an ANSI-accredited standards-developing organization; Secretariat of ISO/TC 209, Cleanrooms and associated controlled environments; Administrator of the ANSI-accredited U.S. TAG to ISO/TC 209; and a founding member of the ANSI-accredited U.S. TAG to ISO/TC 229 Nanotechnologies.

To purchase or obtain more information about these standards and other related recommended practices and working groups, contact IEST at (847) 255-1561, e-mail them at [email protected], or go to the IEST Web site at www.iest.org.

Routine testing ensures standards are being met

By Fran McAteer, Microbiology Research Associates, Inc.

This article presents a testing methodology for environmental monitoring (EM) of viable particles in a cleanroom. Viable particles are living microscopic organisms present in the aseptic environment, especially bacteria, yeast, and mold in the air and on surfaces. Thorough testing usually includes monitoring surfaces, personnel and air. Companies routinely test their cleanroom environments to ensure they meet required standards. Cleanroom operating standards are found in United States Pharmacopeia (USP) and European Pharmacopeia (EP), and International Standards Organization (ISO).

Viable sampling of air

For sampling, gravitational or settling plates are used. These are Petri dishes containing sterile growth media. They are passively exposed to the environment, usually for 30 to 60 minutes. Viable microorganisms that settle onto the media surface grow when the plates are incubated. Though settling plates offer ease of use and remain cost effective, they do not directly correlate microbial contamination with measured air volume and do not provide a quantitative measurement of air contamination.

Another approach is the use of rotary centrifugal air samplers (RCS). These active monitoring instruments measure an exact amount of air with a quantifiable number of viable microorganisms. Contamination can be measured per cubic foot or cubic meter of air (see Fig.1).

Viable sampling of surfaces

Contact or Rodac plates are also Petri dishes containing sterile growth medium. In this case, the agar protrudes above the sides of the plate. The convex contact plate is pressed against any flat, regular surface that needs to be sampled. Any viable microorganisms on that surface will adhere to the agar and grow upon proper incubation. This technique replicates the number of viable microorganisms on a surface. Contact plates are easy to use and widely available, but may not be appropriate for irregular surfaces.


Figure 1. Rotary centrifugal air samplers (RCS) are active monitoring instruments that measure an exact amount of air with a quantifiable number of viable microorganisms. Photo courtesy of Biotest Diagnostics.
Click here to enlarge image

Swabs are used for sampling of uneven surfaces, such as tubing or equipment. Swabbing is qualitative and is technique-dependent. A 2 in2 x 2 in2 sample site is swabbed by using a back and forth technique and rotating 90° and repeating. The swabs are then streaked onto microbiological agar plates for identification.


Figure 2. Swabs are used for sampling of uneven surfaces, such as tubing or equipment. Photo courtesy of ITW Texwipe.
Click here to enlarge image

Viable monitoring of personnel
Personnel working in a cleanroom also need to be monitored for microbial contamination. Personnel monitoring is an indication of gowning proficiency. Sampling sites are located on both gloves and gowns. Touch plates (contact plates) can be used to dynamically monitor technician’s hands immediately after a critical process.

Sampling

Sampling locations are selected based on many factors including potential product exposure areas, processing parameters, equipment design, and validation data. Frequency of monitoring depends on product and quality requirements, and sampling frequency changes should be based on trending analysis and changes in equipment, processing or personnel. A sampling plan describing procedures and identifying sample sites, sampling numbers, and sample frequency should be developed at every regulated company. Testing should be performed during static and dynamic situations.

Action/alert levels

Based on environmental monitoring data, companies must establish action levels, which describe the level of microbial contamination that triggers a planned sequence of corrective actions. The purpose of corrective actions is to return a facility to acceptable limits of viable microorganisms as quickly as possible. These actions will include a determination of what caused the viable counts to be above acceptable limits and how that will be rectified in the future. Exceeding the alert level should cause the company to increase sampling intensity or frequency in the affected area.

Conclusion

Overall, the EM program provides proactive feedback to the cleanliness of a manufacturing operation. It is a proven, effective measurement of quality levels for companies in regulated industries.

Bibliography

1. U.S. Pharmacopeia Convention, Inc. United States Pharmacopeia and National Formulary (USP-NF), 29th edition, Rockville, MD. (2004).


Fran McAteer is vice president of quality at Microbiology Research Associates, Inc. (Acton, MA), an FDA-registered contract microbiology testing laboratory specializing in USP testing for pharmaceuticals, biologics, and medical devices. He has expertise and experience in EM programs and acts as a consultant for many companies. He can be reached via e-mail at [email protected].

Complicated market offers challenges, but overall growth prospects are encouraging

By Robert McIlvaine and Betty Tessien, The McIlvaine Company

Over the four decades of its existence, the cleanroom industry has been good to some investors and a disaster for others. Today the industry is still highly splintered despite the participation of a number of large international companies.

One problem is that the market is defined as a condition rather than a product or an application. Further, this condition is defined by the quantity of particles in the air. Granted, special gloves, garments, filters, walls, monitors, etc., are required for these conditions, but in general, the demands in the ultraclean sector are small compared to the general demands. In other words, the markets for cleanroom wipes and gloves are small compared to other uses such as in manufacturing and hospitals.

Merging similar-but-different technologies

Some years ago, U.S. Filter rolled up several hundred water filtration and treatment companies into a multibillion-dollar enterprise. This effort was built on expansion of a group of products, not a condition. Combining the manufacture of gloves and filters makes very little sense; rather it makes more sense to expand the geography and product varieties of gloves or filters.

Over the last decade a number of cleanroom companies have been acquired by public companies. In general, these companies have already been manufacturing compatible products for non-cleanroom applications.

One concept has been to integrate cleanroom air treatment technology into HVAC systems. Fedders Corporation was a leading example of this strategy. Its acquisition of Envirco, a major supplier of fan filter units and other cleanroom hardware, was followed by international expansion, including development of a good base in China. But for one reason or another, the strategy does not seem to have worked.

In July, Fedders Corporation announced that it had engaged The Blackstone Group to explore the possible sale of the company’s global indoor air quality (IAQ) businesses. It explained that the IAQ businesses were not core to the company’s principal global, residential and commercial HVAC businesses.

Included in the possible sale are the company’s North American IAQ production facility located in North Carolina, two factories in Suzhou, China, and sales offices located in the U.S., the U.K., Germany, China, Malaysia and India.

Fedders has had some rocky times and is appealing the decision by the New York Stock Exchange to suspend trading, beginning November 8, in its common and preferred stock, due to falling below its minimum market capitalization listing standards. Fedders common stock is now trading under the symbol FJCC and Fedders preferred stock under the symbol FJCCP.

Fedders also attempted to marry cleanroom air treatment with air pollution control. It acquired Trion, a major manufacturer of two-stage electrostatic precipitators utilized for in-plant air treatment as well as treatment of exhausts from light manufacturing. The would-be acquirers of the IAQ businesses will have to address whether this is a sound strategy.

Combining cleanroom air treatment and air pollution control does have a number of strengths. For example, the technology development is complementary. Also, the production needs are similar, allowing one factory to produce all the products. The end-user categories overlap somewhat, but the air pollution control systems are sold primarily to commercial restaurants, automobile manufacturers and others not associated with cleanrooms.

The Daikin acquisition of OYL from Hong Leong Group in late 2006 is another example of merging cleanroom technology with air pollution control and HVAC. At the offering, the purchase price was estimated at approximately 239 billion yen. American Air Filter (AAF), which is part of the OYL group, supplies complete engineered cleanroom systems as well as individual HEPA filters and even media for the capture of molecular contaminants.

AAF is a very large supplier of standard air pollution control products and competes with Trion (Fedders), but it also offers a much broader range of air treatment products. It has a number of manufacturing facilities in Asia, but the home office is in Kentucky.

Purafil, Inc. is a leading manufacturer of gas-phase air filtration systems designed to eliminate corrosive, hazardous, odorous and toxic gases. Purafil maintains nearly 20,000 installations worldwide. It is very active in the supply of gas-phase systems for airborne molecular contamination (AMC) elimination in semiconductor plants. Kaydon Corporation acquired the company in 2005.

Purafil has also been successful in selling its media for reducing odors from wastewater treatment plants. The technical challenge is similar to cleanrooms since odors are detectable by the human nose at the very low concentration levels found in cleanrooms.

Kaydon is a diversified manufacturer with a $1.2 billion capitalization. It supplies hydraulic and diesel oil filtration systems to a wide range of end users. But it is also a supplier of a number of unrelated products such as bearings and seals.

Consequently, three major suppliers of cleanroom air treatment products will have changed ownership in the last 24 months.

One very successful example of marrying cleanroom technology with air pollution control is the Donaldson Company. It makes absolute filters used in disk drives, as well as a number of other filtration products. It is also the world’s largest supplier of small air pollution control units. It has expanded vertically through the Tetratec division, which makes membrane media used not only by Donaldson but other filtration companies as well.

Smaller companies with more cleanroom leverage

For the investor, large companies such as Daikin and Kaydon offer relatively little opportunity to translate cleanroom success into stock appreciation. The cleanroom part of the business is just too small a percentage. However, there are some smaller companies whose cleanroom success will impact the bottom line.

Flanders is an example of a public company with cleanroom leverage. It is a vertically integrated company with nine filter assembly plants, two metalworking facilities and a paper mill among its thirteen operating sites. The company’s air filtration products are used in high-technology industries, including semiconductors, ultrapure material handling, biotechnology, pharmaceutical production, synthetics manufacturing and the containment of airborne radioactive particulates in nuclear facilities.

Flanders has a market capitalization of $270 million. Its growth is partially due to an acquisition in the retail filtration area. In the third quarter, it posted earnings of $6.2 million, or 24 cents a share, on revenue of $66.4 million compared with earnings of $3.7 million, or 14 cents a share, on revenue of $63.4 million for the same period last year. It has been trading on the NASDAQ for the last 10 years.

Cleanroom consumables

Cleanroom consumables are a multibillion-dollar world market. The problem is that most of the participants are large companies for which cleanrooms are only a small portion of the total.

For example, Kimberly Clark is a major supplier of cleanroom gloves and wipes, but this activity is minuscule compared to the total revenues of this international integrated manufacturer.

ITW Texwipe has plants in the U.S., Taiwan, Mexico and the Philippines. It supplies a complete array of wipers, swabs, mops, face masks, cleaning solutions and stationery for use in cleanroom environments. In 2001, Texwipe was acquired by Illinois Tool Works (ITW), which designs and produces an array of highly engineered fasteners and components, equipment and consumable systems, and specialty products and equipment. Its 700 decentralized business units in 48 countries employ nearly 50,000 people. So even though ITW Texwipe is one of the largest suppliers of cleanroom consumables, the impact on the corporation is small.

Cintas Corporation is enjoying increased revenues and profits. In the most recent quarter ending in September 2006, it reported revenue of $914.2 million, an 11 percent increase from the previous year’s first quarter revenue of $823.5 million. Net income of $85 million increased 8.3 percent from $78.4 million last year. Cintas expects fiscal 2007 to be another record year, which would result in its 38th consecutive year of growth in sales and earnings.

Cintas provides highly specialized services to businesses of all types throughout North America. The company designs, manufactures and implements corporate identity uniform programs, and provides entrance mats, restroom supplies, promotional products, first aid and safety products, fire protection services and document management services for approximately 700,000 businesses.

Cintas stocks more than 10,000 cleanroom products from 600 manufacturers and suppliers and is a significant player in laundering, processing and distribution in the cleanroom industry. Nevertheless, the impact of this activity on total profits for the company is minor.

Growth in Asia spurs acquisitions

The rapid growth of cleanroom markets in Asia will very likely spur a new round of acquisitions. Some companies, such as Hollingsworth & Vose and Ahlstrom, have expanded through investing in manufacturing facilities in China. Investment in this emerging market will curtail the growth of large Chinese competitors who would otherwise eventually be expanding internationally.

The automobile industry is a prime example of failure to invest in growing markets. After World War II, GM, Ford and Chrysler determined it was not worth the investment to manufacture vehicles with steering wheels on the right side and thus allowed Japanese vehicle manufacturers to grow in an uncontested market.

The lesson today is that, if you don’t establish a presence for your products in China, you will be creating a vacuum that will result in eventual increased competition in your established markets. This is particularly true of the cleanroom industry. The rapid growth of the semiconductor, flat-panel display and other cleanroom industries in China is bound to influence the international rankings of cleanroom suppliers.

One of the routes for growth will be acquisition of Chinese companies. There are some recent examples of this strategy by international investment funds and private investors. These companies will then be acquisition candidates.

In general, investment in the cleanroom industry will continue to be complicated. Nevertheless, the good growth prospects and high margins will make it worthwhile for investors to pursue opportunities.


Robert McIlvaine is president and founder of The McIlvaine Company in Northfield, Illinois. The company first published Cleanrooms: World Markets in 1984 and has since continued to publish market and technical information for the cleanroom industry. He can be contacted at [email protected].

Betty Tessien is the cleanroom publications editor for The McIlvaine Company. She can be contacted at [email protected].

Resolving issues must begin with an understanding of the fundamentals of both contamination and ESD control

By Roger Welker, R.W. Welker Associates

Both contamination levels and electrostatic discharge (ESD) are widely recognized as critical factors affecting yield and reliability in an ever-increasing number of industries. Although contamination has long been recognized as affecting semiconductors, disk drives, aerospace, pharmaceutical and medical device industries, today other industries-such as automobile and food production-are discovering the benefits of contamination control. ESD control has also experienced a similar growth in applications. In fact, today, control of electrostatic charge on surfaces is a widely recognized method of helping to reduce the impact of contamination, providing a synergistic benefit.

Despite the large number of degreed professionals working in contamination and ESD control, these fields remain misunderstood and underappreciated. The misunderstanding often arises because of the interdisciplinary nature of the two fields. Because so many different academic disciplines are required in order to provide a comprehensive understanding, the problems and solutions often appear confusingly complex when, in fact, the vast majority of contamination or ESD problems can be solved using very simple analysis. In addition, there is a long-standing perception that what is good for contamination control is bad for ESD control and vice versa. The following statements clearly point out why this is not the case:

1. Control of charges on surfaces in cleanrooms derives a benefit for contamination control. In this regard, selecting materials with a low tendency to tribocharge and that can be grounded because they are static-dissipative or conductive is desired. However, alone, these two solutions are insufficient in the vast majority of cases and the use of air ionization provides further benefit. Thus, the use of air ionization can provide a benefit for contamination control, regardless of the ESD sensitivity of products or processes within the cleanroom.

2. Control of electrostatic discharge in cleanrooms can provide a benefit by minimizing ESD and EM-induced microprocessor upset, regardless of the ESD sensitivity of products or processes within the cleanroom.

3. Airflow in mixed-flow cleanrooms is not optimized for performance of air ionizers not equipped with fans or compressed air sources. Fan-powered or compressed-gas ionizers are preferred in mixed-flow cleanrooms for this reason. However, fan-powered or compressed-gas ionizers can increase redistribution of contamination and can have a detrimental effect. The requirements of ESD (e.g., discharge time and float potential) must be balanced with contamination (airborne particle count, surface contamination rates, etc.).

4. Ionizers placed near ceilings or bench-mounted HEPA filters can perform well in unidirectional flow applications, particularly for controlling surface contamination. Conversely, airflow in unidirectional flow cleanrooms and clean benches can cause isolation effects or flow stratification, which prevents ionizers from achieving discharge time performance. Proper ionizer deployment must take into consideration cleanroom airflow effects.

5. Ceiling-mounted, room-type ionizers may not provide rapid discharge times. As the ESD sensitivity of devices tends toward lower voltages, only local fan- or gas-powered ionizers can achieve acceptable ESD performance. In these cases, balancing the requirements of ESD failures and contamination failures becomes precarious.

6. All ESD control materials and equipment must be qualified for contamination performance when they are used in contamination-sensitive applications. Similarly, all contamination control materials and equipment must be qualified for ESD performance when they are used in ESD applications.

7. Continuous monitoring systems are available for both contamination and ESD control applications. Their use in workstations that simultaneously require both forms of control can serve to minimize upsets in processes.


Figure 1. This illustration shows the possible effect on airflow of centering the layout of tooling within the process aisle of a cleanroom on a grade-level floor.
Click here to enlarge image

Any attempt at rectifying these two problems should begin with an understanding of the fundamentals of both contamination and ESD control and with defining the specific requirements that must be met. Following this should be an examination of the available analysis methods useful for solving contamination and ESD problems, especially with regard to the selection of materials.

One unconventional approach to building a contamination- and ESD-controlled workplace avoids the conventional approach of discussing the architectural and utility aspects of room construction, and instead focuses on the airflow character within the room and how that airflow is affected by tool and workstation placement (see Figs. 1 and 2).


Figure 2. This illustration shows the possible effect on airflow of bulkhead mounting tools within the process aisle of a cleanroom on a grade-level floor.
Click here to enlarge image

Cleaning processes and the equipment needed to support them must also be considered from the perspective of both the supplier and the user. Design and certification of tooling involves materials selection and evaluation of problems common to all industries affected by contamination and ESD. Continuous monitoring systems for contamination and ESD must also be taken into account.

Consumable materials and supplies should be chosen with a view toward requirements of both contamination and ESD control. In the late 1960s throughout the 1970s, many materials that were good for contamination control were bad for ESD control and vice versa. Today this is no longer true.

Of course, contamination originating from people and how to contain it must be major considerations, along with personnel behavior and discipline. Related to this is one area that has been sadly neglected-that of change-room design and layout.

Finally, overall management of the cleanroom and ESD-protected workplace environments must come into play. Companies dealing with contamination and ESD range in size from those having a single sensitive facility to multinational corporations having cleanrooms and ESD-protected workplaces on virtually every continent.

Roger W. Welker is founder and principle scientist at R.W. Welker Associates, an independent consulting firm specializing in complex contamination, electrostatic discharge, and quality control issues. He can be contacted at [email protected].

Editor’s note: This article contains excerpts from the new book Contamination and ESD Control in High-Technology Manufacturing by Roger Welker, R. Nagarajan, and Carl Newberg (John Wiley & Sons, 2006). In it, “the authors set forth a new and innovative methodology that can manage both contamination and ESD, often considered to be mutually exclusive challenges requiring distinct strategies.”